Skip to content

Does Who Files Change the Outcome?

The answer

Partly, and less than the raw numbers suggest. Small entities are granted 13.2 points less often than large ones. More than half of that travels with technology mix and with who files the application. Hold field, examiner and filing account fixed and 5.8 points remain, and 12.4 for micro entities.

The raw difference

Granted, as a share of resolved applications
1,297,493 US utility applications filed 2020 to 2022 that reached an examiner. Entity status is current, not as filed. Bars run from zero.
Large entity
84.7%
Small entity
71.2%
Micro entity
56.5%

Taken alone this looks like a straightforward difference in treatment. Most of it is not.

Subtracting these rates gives 13.5 and 28.2 points, which is not quite what the adjustment table below reports. The two use different samples: these headline rates cover all 1,235,857 resolved applications, while the model uses the 1,223,976 with a complete art unit, filing year, examiner, account and entity record. Its unadjusted gaps are 13.2 and 27.5 points.

What the difference is made of

Small and large entities do not file the same applications into the same art units. Holding the comparison inside an art unit and filing year, then adding the examiner, then adding the filing account, removes more than half the gap.

Percentage-point gap in grant rate against large entities, 1,223,976 resolved US utility applications filed 2020 to 2022. Standard errors in brackets.
Held fixedSmall entityMicro entity
Nothing, the raw gap-13.2-27.5
Art unit and filing year-8.2-23.2
Plus the examiner-7.8-21.3
Plus the filing account-5.8 (0.14)-12.4 (0.35)
Share of the raw gap left44%45%
The gap against large entities, as each control is added
Percentage-point shortfall in grant rate, 1,223,976 resolved US utility applications filed 2020 to 2022. Each bar is a gap, drawn from zero on the same scale as a share.
Raw gap, small
13.2 pts
Raw gap, micro
27.5 pts
Art unit and year, small
8.2 pts
Art unit and year, micro
23.2 pts
Plus the examiner, small
7.8 pts
Plus the examiner, micro
21.3 pts
Plus the filing account, small
5.8 pts
Plus the filing account, micro
12.4 pts
Reading down, each bar holds one more thing fixed. Most of the raw gap is what gets filed and where: 44% of the small gap and 45% of the micro gap survives to the bottom. The examiner costs 0.4 points for small entities and 1.9 for micro, which is the smallest step of the three.
Our own counts from the USPTO record. Not a causal estimate.

The examiner adds almost nothing: the gap moves by 0.4 points when the examiner is held fixed. Most of what the controls remove is technology and who files.

Examiners in the same art unit do differ

Within a single art unit, the gap between examiners is wider than the gap between entity sizes. Adjusting for the work in front of each examiner narrows it without closing it.

492 art units with 8 or more examiners, 7,785 examiners with 50 or more resolved applications, US utility filings 2020 to 2022. No examiner is identified.
MeasureGrant rate, of resolved
Median art unit grant rate85.2%
Raw gap between examiners, median art unit21.5 points
Adjusted for each examiner's docket13.7 points
Gap expected by chance alone4.9 points
Spread between examiners inside the median art unit
492 art units with 8 or more examiners, 7,785 examiners with 50 or more resolved applications. No examiner is identified. Bars run from zero.
Raw gap between examiners
21.5 pts
Adjusted for each examiner’s docket
13.7 pts
Expected by chance alone
4.9 pts
The bottom bar is the control: some spread would appear even if every examiner behaved identically, because dockets differ and samples are finite. The adjusted gap is about three times that, so it is real, and it is also not the 21.5 points the raw figure suggests. Compared like with like, 13.7 points is wider than the 5.8 point adjusted gap for small entities and about the same as the 12.4 point adjusted gap for micro entities. It is narrower than the raw micro gap of 27.5 points, which is the figure most of that comparison turns out to be technology and who files rather than treatment.

The last row is the one that keeps the finding honest. Some spread between examiners would appear even if every examiner behaved identically, simply because dockets differ and samples are finite. The adjusted gap is about three times that, so it is not noise, but it is not 21.5 points either.

Where the paths actually separate

Following the same applications event by event shows the divergence is on the applicant's side of the exchange, not the examiner's. Micro applicants abandon after a first rejection five times as often as large ones. Among those who do reply, the examiner allows at almost the same rate for everybody.

After a first non-final rejection, by entity size
US utility applications filed 2020 to 2022, each followed 12 months from its own first non-final rejection. Bars run from zero.
Large: abandoned without replying
5.2%
Small: abandoned without replying
14.8%
Micro: abandoned without replying
27.8%
Large: examiner allowed after a reply
50.7%
Small: examiner allowed after a reply
47.8%
Micro: examiner allowed after a reply
47.7%
A 22.6 point difference in whether a reply is filed at all, against a 3.0 point difference in what the examiner does once it is. Lower continuation is a resources-and-support problem, since an employer, assignee or counsel usually controls that budget. It is not evidence about the merits of anybody’s application.
Our own counts from the USPTO record.

These describe what happened across past applications. They say nothing about any particular application, they are associations rather than causes, and none of this is legal advice.

What this does not say

This is an association, not a cause, and not a forecast. It does not say that an application will do better or worse because of who filed it. The things that most determine whether a particular application is granted, the claims and the prior art, are not in these counts at all.
  • The controls cannot see the quality of the application, the budget behind it, or how hard it was pressed. Any of those could account for what remains.
  • Entity status is current rather than as filed, so an applicant whose status changed is recorded under the later one.
  • No examiner is named, here or in the underlying study. Two thresholds apply and they are not the same rule: the examiner comparison counts only examiners with 50 or more resolved applications, and no figure anywhere in this work is published from a cell smaller than 30 applications.
  • A grant rate is not a measure of whether the right applications were granted.

Our own counts from the USPTO record. These describe what happened across past applications. They say nothing about any particular application, examiner or firm, and none of this is legal advice.

The figures on this page are available as a CSV: /data/does-who-files-change-the-outcome.csv. It is generated from the tables and charts above, so it carries the same numbers and cannot fall out of step with them.